Now, some critics also claim that smith gained most of his theories from a manuscript of a novel written by solomon spaulding. This is a fair criticism as long as one acknowledges the complicated process which created the bible and the quran. The next most commonly cited criticism is that the book of mormon has been changed and reinterpreted several times. Notable early critics of mormonism included abner cole, eber d. It is the sacred text for the 15 millionstrong church of jesus christ of latterday saints. The critics best hope to show book of mormon plagiarism. When romney says that he accepts jesus christ as his savior, we appreciate that, haggard said. Whats ironic is that its savage satire and xrated language are tempered by a sweet.
It was first published in march 1830 by joseph smith as the book of mormon. The lds church and mormonism have attracted criticism from their inception to the present day. The book of mormon officially opened thursday at the eugene oneill theatre in new york. Three early critics set the agenda for the first sustained criticisms of the book. If you are investigating mormonism the church of jesus christ of latterday saints or lds church, you are probably studying it in private meetings in your home with missionaries from that church. The book of mormon, the muchapplauded musical from the creators of south park, officially opened in london last week and like the grinning, cleancut missionaries whose story it relates, its been getting some baffled reactions from the locals. The work of comparing the page 51 books was a long, tedious job for a working man. Nitpicking for fun and profit whoever thinks a faultless piece to see.
Notable 20thcentury critics of the lds church include jerald and sandra tanner, richard abanes, richard and joan ostling, and historian fawn m. A challenge to the critics is a carefully documented book that covers a wide spectrum of anti mormon claims concerning the book of mormon. The conclusion states, much as critics and defenders of the book of mormon would like to use dna studies to support their views, the evidence is simply inconclusive. However, the word coins was only added to the chapter heading of alma 11 much later, and the text of the book of mormon itself does not mention coins. Archaeological trends and the book of mormon origins byu. In early 1830 joseph smith published the book of mormon, a 269938 word volume that discusses religious themes intermingled with. The book of mormon chicago opening draws criticism, but. Vulgar and tasteless book of mormon opens broadway series.
In addition, haggard said, evangelicals do not accept mormon church founder joseph smith as a prophet. The cast of the book of mormon performs on stage during the 65th annual tony awards at the beacon theatre on june 12, 2011 in new york city. Nov 01, 2016 as a result, if the book of mormon can be proved to be manmade, then the church is manmade. The critics uniformly misquote joseph smith in this regard, a point i will. Book of mormon geography fits a corner of the americas joseph did not know. Oct 17, 20 the book of mormon opened the fall broadway in new orleans season this week at the saenger theatre.
For the book of mormon s earliest critics, deriding its style was as important as dismantling its truth claims, a way of undercutting the possibility that even if the book was not true scripture, it might still be good fiction. Why is the book of mormon the most criticized book in. I cant figure out why critics spend so much time attacking other aspects of the church. Book of mormon central evidences of the book of mormon. Changing critics criticisms of book of mormon changes. The book of mormon is a vulgar, ugly, offensive and. These are five problems with the book of mormon, and to doubt its authenticity as an ancient. The creators of the animated series south park have brought a musical called the book of mormon to. There are two major fallacies in discussions on this topic. Critics of the book of mormon, trying to prove that the book of mormon isnt true, accused joseph smith of using the name alma in the book of mormon without realizing it was a womans name. Critics are apt to castigate the sentimentalism that often thuds through these books people in them are villains and heroes, the messiness of. Critics challenge the viability of the population size and growth of. Thinks what neer was, nor is, nor eer shall be in every work regard the writers end, since none can compass more than they intend, and if the means be just, the conduct. Critics challenge the viability of the population size and growth of the book of mormon people.
The musical, which features an original book and score by parker, stone and lopez. First is the problem of the hermeneutics of hyperskepticism. Smith, they will say, translated the book of mormon from golden plates he dug up in a hill in new york in the early 1800s. On the topic of the book of mormon, there are many critics. Its a pleasure to be able to say that the australian production lives up to those mighty expectations. Is the book of mormon conservative, as billington argues, because it allows that there might be some upsides to religious belief. The first apologist argument that they did not find archaeological evidence of lions in palestine until very recently is not applicable since pictographic and literary evidence of horses in the new world outside of the book of mormon is unknown.
Book of mormon difficulties, contradictions and explanations. Critics claim that book of mormon references to nephite coins is an anachronism, as coins were not used either in ancient america or israel during lehis day. Why british critics dont get the book of mormon oliver. Aug 12, 2019 praise from critics the book of mormon musical opens in salt lake city this week. However, lets first define the difference between a critic in the academic, critical thinking sense, and a critic in the i hate this book because i hate its author sense. Critics see joseph smith as author of a romantic fiction, the book of mormon, and in so doing they distort both the man and the book beyond belief. Apr 01, 2017 these are five problems with the book of mormon, and to doubt its authenticity as an ancient document. They see the book as a logical product of its 1820s intellectual environment, combined with joseph smiths native intelligence and deceitful propensities. While early critics noticed changes between various editions of the book of mormon, the first book to focus strictly upon those changes was lamoni calls 1898, 2000 changes in the book of mormon. Criticism of the book of mormon wikimili, the best. Critics are apt to castigate the sentimentalism that often thuds through these books people in them are villains and heroes, the messiness of real life condensed into easier answers about who was. The fact that the book of mormon with its length and complexity of manuscript required so few corrections, is substantial evidence and proof that the book is of divine origin. In spite of all the cries of plagiarism by the critics of the book of mormon, i marvel at just how weak the alleged parallels are to other texts that joseph smith might have had access to. And they must explain how joseph smith was able to locate, digest, winnow, and then fashion these materials into a coherent form.
For instance, one man claimed that joseph smith was a blockhead and at the book of mormon was the most gross the most ridiculous, the most emphasis the most contemptible concern to be palmed off on a society as a revelation yet overtime. And we do not believe that the book of mormon has the same level of authority as the bible, he said. A converted antimormon responds to critics of the lds church darrick t. The critics of the book of mormon seem to frequently be of the opinion that a prophet of god is infallible, yet nowhere in the bible is such a thing taught, and lds doctrine does not teach such. Criticism of the church of jesus christ of latterday saints. Mar 30, 2018 some early critics of the book of mormon ridiculed its literary qualities. Scholars reject smiths explanation of the origin of the book of mormon. Praise from critics the book of mormon musical opens in salt lake city this week. Mar 26, 20 why british critics dont get the book of mormon oliver burkeman the south park creators musical was much lauded in the us, but its satirical sensibility may be lost in translation to london. According to a 27 january 2015 lds article written by randal a. Joseph responded to such criticism by affirming an angel had guided him to an ancient record, which he translated by. To those who are investigating mormonism by richard packham. First, the critics must explain how joseph smith, a 23yearold farm boy with limited education, created a book with hundreds of unique names and places, as well as detailed stories and events. For example, critics of mormonism have shown convincing proof that the book of mormon is a synthesis of earlier works written by other men, of the vivid imaginings of joseph smith, and of plagiarisms from the king james bible.
The historicity of the book of mormon religious studies. Who really wrote the book of mormon the critics and their. Many early critics of the book of mormon believed it lacked any literary merit whatsoever, for instance, one man claimed that joseph smith was a blockhead and that the book of mormon was the most gross the most ridiculous, the most emphasize the most contemptible concern to be palmed off upon a society as revelation yet overtime, even some of the book of mormon s most skeptical critics have. Lds church members are taught that the book of mormon bom is scripture, as well as a true record of the inhabitants of the americas from about 2200 bc to 420 ad. Since the opening of the book of mormon, many theater critics have been effusive in their praise of the broadway and touring productions, lauding both its qualities as a musical and how it treats subjects that some hold sacred. Incidentally, not all 19th century critics of the book of mormon agreed this was a plagiarism of shakespeare. A common response from critics to this type of argument is to show, or at least claim, that a roughly contemporary book or source from which he. Over the years, many critics of the book of mormon have acknowledged its merits.
This first in a planned series of films devoted to telling the tale of the mormon faith in america, the book of mormon charts the recorded history of nephi noah danby as he leads his people from. Lamb may have been the very first critic to suggest that the book of mormon has an unrealistic population growth rate. When mormon missionaries properly called latter day saints or simply lds come to your door, they will often offer a free copy of the book of mormon and tell you about its author, joseph smith. Apr 30, 2019 its not and i would discourage anyone from thinking that it is. The opponents of the historicity of the book of mormon must prove that the people whose religious life it records did not live anywhere in the americas. The book of mormon is the smartest, funniest and most refreshing new musical to come out of broadway in years. Internet bloggers simply say its common sense that if israelite blood isnt found in the modern descendants of book of mormon people, then the book is a fraud. Book answers dna critics of book of mormon deseret news. The book of mormon gets the literary treatment religion. When the criticisms of the book of mormon cant be taken seriously. Critics might state that the book of mormon is not prophesied of by name in the bible. There were writings and drawings of lions in palestine and horses used by the. A fundamental fallacy of critics of the book of mormon is that they ignore this linguistic complexity, conflating twentyfirst century english categories and concepts with those of these other linguistic layers.
For instance, dan vogel and brent lee metcalfe have described it as. Once we have a foundational testimony of the book of mormon, then. She was born to mormon fundamentalist parents in idaho, the youngest of seven. In this book evenson presents a rebuttal for each of the doctrines for which members of the mormon church are criticized. The writers of the book of mormon musical focus their story on two groups of people, but it is clear from the text that they, themselves, are outsiders of both.
Instead of picketing the book of mormon musical, for example, the mormon church. Critics claim that language patterns in the book of mormon indicate that it is merely a repetition of rhetorical patterns found in the old testament. However, as elder callister pointed out, the name of jesus christ is not prophesied of in the old testament. Evenson has shared that his reason for writing the book was to provide mormons with scriptures from the bible alone to demonstrate that criticism of mormon religion cultism is unfounded and that most all of the doctrines of the lds latterday saints are supported by. Even before the book of mormon came off the press in 1830, newspaper articles criticized the book and its translator, joseph smith. Over time, however, its become clear that the book of mormon is actually a remarkably complex and sophisticated text. The book of mormon is a sacred text of the latter day saint movement, which, according to adherents, contains writings of ancient prophets who lived on the american continent from approximately 2200 bc to ad 421. The criticisms of the book of mormon fall into several categories some of which are legitimate and some of which are not. Changing critics criticisms of book of mormon changes the.
Why is the book of mormon the most criticized book in history. Critics of the book of mormon now seem forced to follow the agenda set out by brodiethey must locate nineteenthcentury sources for all its contents. May 23, 2017 t he book of mormon is a wholly american scripture. The methodology employed by call was unsophisticated. The 3,9 mistakes which critics use to substantiate their claim that the book of mormon is not true, are indeed minor changes such as punctuation. A converted antimormon responds to critics of the lds church. Peterson argues that the science the book s critics use is unsound. Joseph responded to such criticism by affirming an angel had guided him to an ancient record, which he translated by the gift and power of god. And a hefty portion of its laughs come at the expense of those friendly doortodoor mormons. Contrary to reverend lamb and subsequent critics, the book of mormon does have a place in the americasjust not a place in joseph smiths experience. Sure, its protagonists are a pair of missionaries in africa. These are five problems with the book of mormon, and to doubt its authenticity as an ancient document.
Howe each alleged joseph smith used the book of mormon as part of an elaborate scheme to defraud the public. Critics of the book of mormon but the miracle of its existence remains the keystone of our religion even today. In fact, the first articles criticizing the book of mormon appeared before it was even published. Therefore, the books geography could not have derived from his personal experience. Then, in the 1960s, a jewish not lds scholar found a document that dated back to the time of lehi. It systematically exposes fraudulent assertions by presenting irrefutable evidences drawn from the findings of historians, anthropologists and archaeologists. The longawaited return of a hit broadway musical to the venerable arts. Jan 31, 2015 many critics claim that the book of mormon is nothing more than a book of fiction, and joseph smith, whom they further claim is a fraud, is its author.
To those who are investigating mormonism the mormon church. Its rare that a musical opens in australia with expectations as high as the book of mormon. The book of mormon claims that moroni, a prophet, originally wrote the book and that it was translated by joseph smith. The book of mormon weathers claims of critics mormon church. Nov 15, 2017 latent antimormon bias may seem harmless enoughafter all, mormons are reluctant to call others out on it. Mar 25, 2011 the book of mormon officially opened thursday at the eugene oneill theatre in new york. The historicity of the book of mormon religious studies center. Many early critics of the book of mormon believed it lacked any literary merit whatsoever. Its one of broadways hottest tickets, completely sold out since it opened six years ago, thrilling critics and audiences alike, and developing a massive following. The 1st rule of book of mormon evidence there is no. Do those errors make the book of mormon any less correct. For this reason, the critics are intent on disproving the book of mormon, but the obstacles they face are insurmountable because this book is true. Since there has been a lot of criticism by some antimormons about the steelusing nephites, it might be useful to see what the book of mormon actually says about iron and steel.
However, the collection of scholarly writings refutes that argument, peterson said. Well, the ones who work as professional theatre critics, anyway. Along with cocreator robert lopez, parker and stone have produced a work of comedic genius that exceeds critical hype and hyperbole. Mormon movies are a burgeoning industry in utah, and despite the niche audience and low budgets, some of them hold their own with hollywood in terms of storytelling and entertainment value. Why british critics dont get the book of mormon oliver burkeman. The book of mormon musical arrives in salt lake for the. The book of mormon, published in 1830 by american religious leader joseph smith, has been the subject of criticism relating to its origin, text, and historical accuracy.
The book of mormon is a sacred text of the latter day saint movement, which adherents believe contains writings of ancient prophets who lived on the american. The only bible that joseph smith relied on was the king james version. On the other hand, if its origin is godgiven, then joseph smith was a prophet, and if he was a prophet, then the church of jesus christ of latterday saints is true. An account written the book of mormon is a sacred text of the latter day saint movement, which adherents believe contains writings of ancient prophets who lived on the american continent from approximately 2200 bc to ad 421.
393 1156 1613 492 228 1534 1035 43 1056 641 417 301 497 1169 655 1334 1143 1417 1419 1598 974 886 1080 539 823 1456 914 1276 432 672 939 346 866 717 980